Colton Bell - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2022
David Sugar - Mr. Mayhem Leather Bear 2022

Duke - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2021
Ben Smith - Mr. Mayhem Leather Bear 2021

Pup Lucky - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2019-2020
Joe Ether - Mr. Mayhem Leather Bear 2019-2020

Pup Baxter - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2018
Jeff Miller - Mr. Mayhem Leather Bear 2018

Joey Watson - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2017
Keith Greene - Mr. Mayhem Leather Bear 2017

Ash Duncan - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2016

Kevin Michael O'Connell - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2015

Chad Baylor - Mr. Mayhem Leather 2014